I wasn't sure how I would like this at first as I've always used soft bag holders, but this one's sold me on the simple plastic ones. It does exactly what it needs to do, it's offered in a few different colors, and no frills. Initially I hated the little plastic bone clip, but I think if I swapped it for a metal carabiner that it would risk snapping the little tab off if it got jammed someplace. It seems sturdy enough and is flexible so it shouldn't break unless it was seriously smashed. Mostly, I appreciate how easy this thing was to open and load (even with my arthritic hands), and it's easy to get one bag out without pulling out the whole roll on accident. Coming with two rolls of bags out of the package is also a nice touch.

I received this product for free from the Spotted by Petco sampling program in exchange for my honest review. It is a 'cute' little dispenser with a handy clip for the waste bags. Seems like it will hold up well and is something I will use for a long time.