Cats didn't like it for more than one sniff. I have 3 cats. None of them played with it.

mybl 2 cats LOVE THESE, played all afternoon with them

These fish are her favorite toy, but for some reason she tore one apart

The cats love them. The catnip is a favorite for both Butler and Luigi!

I got these Catnip toys for my two adult cats. The primary interest was to get them to be more active as the older of the pair has a weight issue and I hoped this would get him to have more interest in playing with the other cat. Both cats went right to the Catnip toys with intrigue. They played with them for about 30 minutes, trying to carry them in their mouth. The little fins are thin and cats can use this to pickup and carry it around the house with them. However, after about half an hour they seemed to lose interest. I am not sure if the Catnip is not potent enough to have a strong effect on them. I tried bringing them out the next day but they only were marginally interested.

Product was great! My cat really liked playing with them. She would toss them all over the place until eventually we couldn't find them. She loved rubbing her face on them too. Catnip tends to overstimulate her so we try to limit the products we use. This one was nice that she would play with it multiple short periods of time .

Well, the cats must have really liked them because they are hidden. I have three cats, but only two toys. The younger cats immediately took them somewhere, leaving the older cat with nothing. They are in the house somewhere. I see Cheddar with one every now and then, but he keeps it hidden. I am not sure where Tuxer put hers. Poor Indy. He never had a chance.

My cat Zelda loved smacking these around for literal hours. She kept knocking them under the couches and would meep until we went and retreved them for her to keep playing with. She never tried to eat them. Just smack.