My cat goes crazy for it, but destroyed the included toy the first time he caught it and ran off with it. The metal clasp that keeps the toy attached quickly stretches out to the point where even flicking it makes the toy come loose. I have to squeeze it shut with my teeth to get it to stay on. Then, the first time the cat catches the toy, it pops off again. I got a replacement toy that also fell apart within a few uses. I've had to hot glue everything back together. Bad design.

Why are these both in the same sku? Almost all reviews are people asking for the same thing. Let us pick the one that works for our pets

Bought this last night and my cat really loves it, but the feathers are already falling out this morning.

I brought this five half years ago as it got worn out so I happened to see it there so I grabbed to get another one so now my cat is so so happy with new one .

I thought it was two, since the picture shows two, but it’s only one.

my cat LOVES this toy but the one with the ball, is CHEAP! We have been through a handful and its hard to buy a specific one because they say its "their choice" which one we get, which I disagree with

OK, first: Great toy, 5 stars so you read this, but really only 4 stars, and only because I keep looking for replacements for this toy and can't find them. Site says 'assorted variety' at store, but can't find this particular one at the store. (And, no, I don't want to allow you to select one for me on line. I want the brisket, not the round.) I buy these more than one at a time when I see them because of this - as cat toys do wear out, get chewed, carried, tossed, presented. And when they love it, more so. Not finding it is the only bad part? My cat really really loves this thing. Absolute favorite toy. Don't quite get whatever odd fur-with-feathers animal this might suggest to him, but he just loves it. Half mouse, half bird? Who knows. But I can spin him in circles with this toy. Like all feathered things cats catch, he will instinctually try to break feathers off it so that 'dinner' can't fly away - so I try to not let him keep it long after I let him catch it, or leave it where he can get it while I'm at work. But even with no feathers, he loves these. I toss them when the poly-fur body starts to unravel. He also likes to play with just the string on the wand, after the toy is gone.

I purchased 4 of these in the same order hoping to get the one that isn't a ball to replace my cats woobie and all 4 were the ball one that she isn't really interested in. If you were able to select the one you wanted I would give this 5 stars but to get 4 of the same and not the one I was looking for was very disappointing